TRUSTED EXPERIENCE IN WEST CENTRAL INDIANA

Where You Live Is My Business.

And helping you start your next chapter is my privilege.

(765) 230-6335

About Me

Real estate decisions are too important for guesswork - that’s where experience matters.

As a lifelong resident of Crawfordsville with 18+ years of experience as a Certified Appraiser and a Top 3 ranking in Montgomery County, I provide data-driven expertise that most agents can’t. Since 2020, I’ve closed 262 transactions totaling over $57M, placing me in the top 5% of Indiana agents. I’ve spent my life walking these lands and visiting these neighborhoods, which is why I live by a simple professional standard: Where you live is my business.

With nearly 20 years of experience and a specialized background as an Indiana Certified Appraiser, I provide more than just a listing; I provide the data-driven expertise and local insight you need to move with absolute confidence. Whether you are buying your first home, selling the family farm, or seeking acreage across West Central Indiana, I treat your investment with the same care and seriousness as my own.

Rooted In Results

99.4%

List-to-Sale Ratio (2026)

Top 3

Agents in Montgomery County

$57M+

Sales Volume Since 2020

18+ Years

Professional Valuation Experience

2020

Montgomery Realtor of the Year

2020 and 2024

Nominee for Indiana State Realtor of the Year

F.C. Tucker

President’s Club Recipient

You Defended Our Homes.

Now Trust Me With Yours.

As a thank you for your service, I am proud to offer the Military On The Move (MOM) program. This isn’t just a service – it’s a tribute to the men and women who have sacrificed for our community.

The Promise: If you are a Veteran, Active Duty, Retired, or a Wounded Warrior, you will receive a 20% rebate of my commission at closing.

Because where you live is my business – and honoring your service is my privilege.

Featured Counties

Room to Breathe. Room to Grow. Indiana.

Montgomery County

Boone County

Fountain County

Hendricks County

Parke County

Putnam County

Tippecanoe County

Vermillion County

Where You Live Is My Business

Simple Guidance. Complete Support.

Expert Valuation

As a Certified Appraiser, I don’t guess – I know. You get the most accurate pricing data to buy or sell with total confidence. Unlike a standard market analysis, I apply my 18 years of appraisal experience to every listing, maintaining a 99.4% list-to-sale price ratio for my clients in 2026

Strategic Marketing

Every home has an ideal buyer – I find them. Before listing, I analyze the property, location, and price to target the right audience and market directly to them, not just everyone.

Local Knowledge. Professional Advantage.

Montgomery County isn’t just where I work – it’s home. My deep roots here give clients real insight into the neighborhoods, market, and community – so every decision is guided by experience, not guesswork.

Testimonials

Proof That Where You Live Truly Is My Business.

Bought a Single Family home in 2022 in Crawfordsville, IN. I recommend John without reservation! John is very knowledgeable about the area and housing market. He went above and beyond to make our transition smooth. He listened to our wish list and found the perfect dream home for us. We couldn’t be happier!

-Clay and ConnieWatson

Sold a home in 2022. Too often people use real estate agents that do not know the market they are selling in. I really believe the value of an agent is knowing the market inside and out. When it comes to Montgomery county, John knows it all. He is easy to work with and goes the extra mile. If you are buying or selling anywhere near Crawfordsville, Indiana, your first call should be to John.

-mike22463

Bought and sold a home in 2025. This is the 2nd time using John. He was a huge help buying/selling our house. If you want someone who is knowledgeable, experienced and always quick to respond he is the guy. We wouldn’t use anyone else other the John Downey.

-landonnave101

John Downey worked with us as we bought our current home. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience! John is so kind, professional, responsive, and knowledgeable. We felt so comfortable having him with us during the whole process! Go see John, you won’t be disappointed!

-Kathryn Foland

Some of the greatest experience I have had purchasing a house from start to finish! John Downey is the best agent I have ever worked with! I highly recommend giving him a call if you're looking to buy or sell!

-Alan Griggs

We were thrilled with John Downey from FC Tucker West Central. He put the property on the market and we had a cash offer within a week! We will definitely use him again

-Kathryn Eads

Your Next Chapter Begins Here